Songbook albums were considered cool and trendy in the late '90s, and that seemed to fit into
Lester Bowie's pop-tune agenda with the
Brass Fantasy. But he wouldn't be bound to the usual worshipful homages on bended knee to a single composer, directing his
Brass Fantasy (brass ensemble plus drums/percussion) toward a mind-boggling assortment of sources that are often thoroughly contemporary. Hence a record that pits
Cole Porter back-to-back with
Marilyn Manson,
Andrew Lloyd Webber with the
Spice Girls, or how about
Notorious B.I.G. with
Giacomo Puccini!
Bowie's Brass Fantasy is at the ensemble's best when they swagger irreverently through "The Birth of the Blues" or a doo wop "In the Still of the Night" -- and the
Manson track, "Beautiful People," is savage, even raucous fun. Other songs are taken quite seriously; the
Spice Girls' "Two Become One" becomes a sophisticated ballad chart. However, the
Bowie band cannot relieve the tedium of
Lloyd Webber's quasi-tango "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" by doing it relatively straight, and they seem a bit intimidated by
Puccini's "Nessun Dorma" -- which is probably beyond the reach of a jazz treatment anyway. At the very least, the brasses sound fresh and interested in what they're doing, so there is pleasure to be had here.
–
Richard S. Ginell, Rovi